Comparing some Japanese kanji to ids

I no longer have as favorable a view of  Chinese characters/Japanese kanji as I used to.  I now think they have their strong and bright points, but are generally shot.  They are way, way too complex and just chock full of nonsense.  They are old–primitive attempts at representing ideas graphically.  Their forms are limited by the fact that they were originally written with brush and ink.  Modern writing instruments allow much more versatility–neat little circles, filling in,  and much more detail.

In the short selection below of kanji and their id equivalents, I would guess that the ids take generally a fifth or less time to write.  And ids represent things and ideas with more true-to-lifeness and thus are much easier to recognize. On top of that, ids are embedded in “families” with the same or related components for related ideas.  A major class of these families is “graphic opposites,” in which ideas with opposite meanings are represented with graphically opposing elements–see good/bad, short/long, and the directions NSEW. Compare these ids to the kanji and you’ll see that the ids are much clearer and simpler.

Scan0131   Scan0132  Scan0133  Scan0134  Scan0135  Scan0136


About ErnieM

Live near Seattle, USA.
This entry was posted in ideograms, writing systems and tagged . Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s